Charlotte Smith and Laura-Lise Jeanine Wong
It started with a number of posts in city Facebook groups across Mexico asking variations of a fairly straightforward question.
“What do people think about the use of AI?”
The responses surprised us. Not because people had different opinions about artificial intelligence. That’s to be expected. It was how quickly the conversations moved towards what the technology could do for businesses, with so little consideration for the people whose work and livelihoods are most affected.
There was plenty to say about saving money, embracing technology, ease of use, and accepting that the world is changing. Much less was said about the writers, photographers, designers, illustrators, and other creative professionals trying to work out what those changes might mean for their futures. It prompted a conversation between the two of us about how differently people tend to talk about small businesses when the people behind them have a welcoming front door.
We understand their struggles, and we rally around them. A lot. We remind people to support them because we know there are real people behind those businesses, trying to make a living. So why, we wondered, did that same consideration seem so absent when the people whose livelihoods were being discussed were creatives?
That conversation grew into a much larger question about who we actually mean when we talk about supporting local businesses in Mexico, and why some livelihoods seem to inspire more empathy than others.
We encourage people to eat at independent restaurants, shop at local markets, hire local tradespeople, and spend their money with businesses that help keep their communities going. We understand that behind a restaurant counter is someone with bills to pay, employees to support and rising costs to manage. Choosing an independent business over a large chain can make a real difference to that person’s livelihood.
But what about the people whose businesses don’t have a counter? The ones who can’t serve their product on a plate with a little added garnish?
Mexico is home to plenty of Mexican and foreign creative professionals who earn their living from a keyboard rather than a shopfront. They might work from a home office, a spare bedroom, a shared co-working space, or a desk in the corner of a coffee shop. But they’re running businesses all the same. Some have university degrees, professional qualifications, and decades of experience. Others have developed their skills through practical experience, building careers that allow them to work independently.
They’re finding clients, meeting deadlines, and paying bills, just like the business owners we readily encourage others to support. They’re not retired, living on pensions, doing the work as a hobby, or running a business for a bit of extra spending money. This is their livelihood. Their only livelihood. It’s how they pay rent, support their families, feed and clothe themselves, and contribute to the communities in which they live. Their clients might be closer than we think.
A graphic designer working from home in Manzanillo could create a logo for a restaurant down the road. A photographer in Mérida might work with local families, tourists, hotels and businesses. A writer could tell the stories of the community in which she lives, while a web developer builds a website for a Mexican entrepreneur.
The work happens online, but the client might be just around the corner. The money earned can support a household and circulate through the same communities we’re all encouraged to support.
Yet these businesses often disappear from the conversation when we talk about shopping locally.
Consider Puerto Vallarta, where art and creativity are an established and heavily promoted part of the city’s identity. The sculptures along the Malecón, the galleries of Centro Histórico, the long-running ArtWalk, artisan markets and cultural events all help make the destination what it is. They’re part of what visitors come to experience and what the city promotes to the world.
But creativity contributes to the local economy in less obvious ways, too. It’s the photographer capturing a restaurant’s atmosphere, the designer developing its visual identity, the illustrator creating its packaging, and the writer telling its story to potential customers. Their work helps businesses attract attention, establish credibility, and stand out in a crowded market. A photograph might persuade someone to try a new restaurant. A well-designed website might give a customer the confidence to book a service. Distinctive branding might make a small business instantly recognisable.
We see the finished results every day. We photograph them, share them, marvel at them and sometimes make purchasing decisions because of them. What we don’t always see is the professional expertise behind them, or the business providing it. We can be quick to defend an independent restaurant facing rising food costs or a shop struggling to compete with larger retailers. We understand that these businesses need customers to survive, and that their owners can’t keep giving things away and hope the bills somehow get paid.
But when a photographer loses a booking because someone chooses an AI-generated image, or a designer watches a potential client replace a paid commission with an AI-generated logo, the conversation changes.
“Technology is progress,” we’re told.
“You’d better learn to adapt.”
“If someone can produce something more cheaply, why wouldn’t they?”
There are legitimate reasons for businesses to think this way. Budgets are finite, and small-business owners have every right to look for ways to save money. AI tools can be accessible and genuinely helpful, particularly for entrepreneurs who can’t afford to outsource every task.
This isn’t an argument that AI should be banned or that businesses should be expected to pay for services beyond their means. But we can acknowledge the benefits of new technology without dismissing the people whose work it may replace.
Generative AI can create images, text, designs, and campaigns by drawing on patterns learned from vast amounts of existing material, including work produced by human creatives. The technology is changing rapidly, and the questions surrounding its use are complex. But the people whose skills are being affected are real, too.
For some, this isn’t an abstract debate about innovation. It’s a question of whether they’ll continue to earn enough to support themselves. And we shouldn’t have to agree on every aspect of AI to show some consideration for that reality.
We’ve noticed something else in these conversations, too. When we try to explain our concerns to people enthusiastically promoting AI for their businesses, our words can be received as an attack on their choices rather than an invitation to consider another perspective. Responses can be surprisingly defensive, even dismissive, as though questioning the impact of a technology is somehow unreasonable.
We don’t know whether that defensiveness comes from feeling criticised, frustration at being challenged, guilt, or something else entirely. Perhaps the conversation feels different when we stop talking about AI in general and start talking about the actual people whose livelihoods are affected by it, including people we know and call friends.
We’re not asking anyone to abandon tools that help them run their businesses. We’re simply asking for room in the conversation for the people on the other side of the equation.
The ability to save money and the impact of that saving on someone else’s livelihood can both be real. Acknowledging one doesn’t require us to pretend the other doesn’t exist.
There’s another part of this conversation that predates AI by years. The expectation that creative work shouldn’t necessarily cost anything.
If you work in a creative field, you’ll probably recognise the requests.
“Could you just look this over and make a few changes?”
“Can you do a quick headshot?”
“Would you mind putting together a little logo?”
“Could you write something up for me?”
“It’s only a small favour. It won’t take long.”
Except that those few minutes might represent years of experience, professional training, expensive equipment and skills that took considerable time and effort to develop. A photographer still needs to edit the photographs they’ve taken. A writer still needs to research and craft the words. A designer still needs to develop a concept and make revisions.
Sometimes, the work really does take only a few minutes precisely because the person doing it has spent years learning how. That’s the bit we seem to forget. We ask for someone’s professional expertise precisely because they know what they’re doing, then sometimes treat the work as though it can’t possibly be worth much because they make it look easy.
Of course, people help friends, neighbours, non-profits and other business owners all the time. Generosity is part of what makes a community a community. There’s nothing wrong with offering professional help as a favour when you choose to do so. The distinction is between offering that help willingly and someone assuming it’s available simply because the work looks easy.
We wouldn’t walk into a clothing shop and ask the owner to give us a pair of trousers because we only need them for one occasion. We wouldn’t order an entrée at a restaurant and expect the chef to prepare it for free because it’s only one quick to make plate.
Creative work is no different.
Part of the problem may be that it’s less visible. We can walk into a shop and see the premises, the stock, the till, and the employees. A creative professional might work alone from home, with no sign above the door. But running that business still involves finding clients, marketing services, maintaining equipment and software, managing accounts, handling revisions, and making sure there’s enough income to cover expenses.
The creative isn’t simply doing the bit we see on the screen. They’re running a business around it, and that business needs to be sustainable. Independent businesses often support one another, creating relationships that help keep money moving through the local economy. A restaurant might hire a local photographer to showcase its menu, commission a designer for its signage or work with a web developer to attract customers. A hotel might hire a writer to tell its story. A wedding planner might commission stationery from an independent illustrator.
Those aren’t charity projects. They’re business relationships. The business purchasing the service gets something it needs, while the creative professional earns an income and can then spend that money at other local businesses. It’s the same principle we understand when we encourage people to buy produce from local suppliers or choose an independent shop over a national chain. Yet we don’t always apply that thinking to the services businesses purchase.
This matters for Mexican creatives and for foreigners who’ve established their own businesses in Mexico. Supporting local doesn’t have to mean supporting only businesses we can physically walk into. A Mexican designer might build a brand for a foreign-owned restaurant. A foreign photographer might help a local family celebrate a wedding. A freelance writer might introduce a small Mexican business to an international audience.
Some independent professionals earn money from international customers; others work primarily with people and businesses in their own towns. Many do both. Whatever their client base, their work can contribute to the communities where they live.
Those Facebook discussions prompted us to look again at something we often take for granted. Our commitment to supporting local businesses.
We say we want independent businesses to thrive, and that we recognise the pressures they face and understand that the people behind them deserve the opportunity to earn a living. Perhaps we simply need to widen our understanding of what a local business looks like. Not every entrepreneur has employees. Not every business has premises. Not every service comes with a physical product. And not every livelihood is visible to the people who benefit from the work.
Sometimes it’s a photograph, a design, a story, or an idea. The person behind it might be a Mexican photographer, a foreign freelance writer, a local illustrator, or a web developer working from a spare bedroom. They might be serving clients across the world or helping a business on the next street attract more customers.
They’re still building a business. They’re still contributing to the economy. And they’re still just trying to make a living.
We can embrace technology while recognising the people affected by it. We can appreciate the convenience of inexpensive tools without assuming professional expertise has become worthless. And we can make room in our idea of supporting local for the people whose work we may never see being done. The work of creative professionals might happen behind a screen rather than across a counter, but the person, the effort, the time, the talent, and the livelihood are very, very real.
Perhaps it’s time we extended our idea of supporting local to include them, too.